Tuesday, 10 December 2024

Radiomaster GX12 with ELRS Gemini: a review


Radiomaster GX12

Once in a while a transmitter comes along which is genuinely different and interesting... which is why I was excited to review the GX12, a compact radio from Radiomaster with a bunch of novel features.

Because of the GX12's support for Xrossband/XGem, one might assume that it's mainly for drone pilots. However, the GX12 also supports regular single channel ELRS, making it compatible with PWM receivers like the Radiomaster ER series and Matek 24R P6V... and this makes the GX12 potentially interesting for line-of-sight pilots like me - and maybe you too.

So, here is my review. I hope you enjoy reading it!

Style and build quality 

First impressions are good: the GX12 comes packed in a sweet little carry case, with internal padding, and a pocket for accessories. Open the case, and there it is, ready to play!

The styling is quite striking - a mixture of soft corners and edgy angles. It looks functional yet also a teeny bit radical. (Does this herald a new direction for Radiomaster, I wonder?)

Fit and finish are good, with the exception of the trims which are a little rattly. 

There's no carry handle, instead there’s a smart fabric strap with the Radiomaster logo. It does the job and keeps the unit compact. One nice detail is that the GX12 is perfectly stable when standing on its base. 

front view of Radiomaster GX12 transmitter
Top view. Centre ports are headphone jack, USB-C and DSC ports

Case design and ergonomics

The GX12 is squat and dense - think of it as a mini sumo wrestler, and you have the idea! It feels a little less secure in the hand than the taller TX16S, though using a neckstrap improves stability. 

The sticks are well positioned and stick spacing is generous for a compact set, being identical to the TX16S. 

The switch legends are engraved in white and are easy to read - a welcome improvement on previous Radiomaster offerings. 

There's a comprehensive selection of widgets, comprising two momentary pads, two momentary buttons, two rollers, and four swappable switches. Included are two spare switches. There's also an array of six illuminated buttons. More about these later.

The programming controls follow the usual RM convention. The programming buttons have a nice feel. The click roller is quite small, though.

Programming controls on GX12
Programming controls

A high-contrast OLED monochrome display is located near the top of the case. 

A view of the OLED display on the GX12
OLED monochrome display

The display itself is small and resolution is just 128*64, so any programming is best done using EdgeTX Companion.

The antennas are short and rigid and may be folded flush when not in use - just like the antenna on the the Zorro.

Configurable buttons

Along the bottom are six buttons with built in RGB LEDs.  These offer a number of interesting possibilties.

A view of the programmable button array
Configurable button array

The buttons are configured in the Model Setup menu:

  • A button can act like a momentary, or push-on/push-off. 
  • A button may be 'independent', or part of a group where only one button is active at any time. 
  • The startup state of an 'independent' is configurable to On/Off/As-last
  • The startup state of a group is also configurable
  • The LED colours for the on/off states can be set individually for each button. 

Very clever and flexible. Below are some possible applications:

  • Arming gesture: push the end buttons together for n seconds to arm.
  • Two sets of triple rates (or three sets of dual rates), with a designated default at startup. 
  • Flight mode selection

Note that you can't change the state of a switch programmatically, only by physically pressing it. So for example, you can't use their LEDs to indicate the state of something else. 

A full evaluation of the buttons' usefulness will await flight testing.

Swappable switches

There's another surprise in store… the clue being the Allen bolts in the switch panels.

Top view of a switch panel on the Radiomaster GX12
RH panel showing momentary (SH), 3-pos (SF, SC) and roller

Undo the bolts and lift off the panel, and voila you have full access to two switches, the roller and a momentary button. These all connect to a small PCB. 

The roller and momentary button are soldered directly to the PCB.

The two switches are connected via cables to the motherboard, and these can be removed or swapped. As delivered, all four installed switches are 3-position types. In addition, a momentary and 2-position  switches are provided separately in a bag. 

Swapping a switch is just a question of removing one and plugging in another. A slight niggle is that no tool is provided for the switch retaining nuts (fortunately I already had one).

View of the switch PCB removed from the case of the GX12
Panel removal

Fixed momentaries (SH and SG)

If I have a niggle with the GX12 it's the momentary buttons SH, SG. These are located on the shoulders, just where F3X sailplane wing pilots would expect to find a 3-position switch. Unfortunately these buttons cannot be swapped out since they're soldered to the daughter board. 

It would be nice if Radiomaster could address this with an alternative panel however it would also necessitate a different design for the daughter board.

Also included is a pair of panels without slots for the roller. 


Top view of accessories provided with the GX12
Alternative panels (without roller slots) and extra switches

Now here's a nice detail: the plastic posts which receive the panel bolts have threaded metal inserts. No worries about stripping the threads!

The pots near the bottom of the case are commendably smooth, with a positive centre detent. Good for secondary functions like speaker volume. 

View of two potentiometers on Radiomaster GX12
Cute little pots!

Gimbals

The gimbals are top quality CNC units with multiple ball bearings and 3D Hall effect sensors. 

The 3D sensors are an interesting development. Gone are those pesky cables from gimbal to motherboard! Instead, the magnet, sensor and electronics are all on the main PCB. No cables means no more risk of fractured solder joints.

There's also a useful mechanical feature: pull smartly on a stick, and a hinged joint is exposed, allowing the stick to be folded flat. Straighten the stick, and a spring pulls it back in position ready for use. No need for gimbal protectors!


A view of the left-hand stick of the Radiomaster GX12 after being folded flat
Fold-flat sticks!

The gimbals themselves are silky smooth, with a satisfying ‘clack’ on hitting the end stops - rather similar to the excellent AG01 gimbals.

I did however notice a very subtle asymmetry in spring tension; when moving the sticks outwards the tension is slightly weaker than when pushing inwards especially as the end outer stop is approached. Holding the lower/inner diagonal is also easier then the higher/outer. It's not a showstopper (I suspect that most users won't notice the difference unless it's pointed out).

Spring tension and throttle friction are adjustable with an allen key through holes under the side cheeks.  Switching between modes 1 and 2 is accomplished in a similar way.

Shot of soft springs and allen key
Soft springs and allen key

Each stick's vertical travel can be altered via adjusters on the front face (remember to re-calibrate the sticks after adjustment).

View of access holes for gimbal adjustment
Access holes for gimbal adjustment


RF module with ELRS/Gemini/Xrossband

The feature most touted by Radiomaster is the internal module which supports a number of transmission modes from single channel ELRS, to dual-band Gemini Xrossband. 

Compared with single band/single-channel ELRS, Gemini Xrossband offers better link quality (but not necessarily greater ultimate range) in areas of high interference. However, it's unlikely to offer any significant benefit for sailplane pilots given the relatively short ranges that we fly. 

If you would like to know more about Gemini, please see the links at the end.


View of the twin antennae on the GX12
Hello, bunny rabbit!

RF power is 1W max per band. The module is equipped with a heat sink (just visible inside the case) and cooling fan. For line of site flying with 100mW is more than sufficient, and will not trigger the fan.

Battery

A battery box is provided for two 18650 LiIon batteries. Alternatively it will accept a 21700 2S pack. Batteries are not provided with retail units.

Radiomaster stipulate the use of batteries with a nominal voltage of 3.7V and end voltage of 4.2V for compatibility with the internal charger.

View of battery compartment on RM GX12
Batteries compartment incorporates a reset switch

Charging is via the USB port at the top of the radio. The port is also used for data transfer.

EdgeTX

My set came with a development version of EdgeTX 2.11.0 which is not compatible with the latest version of Companion at the time or writing (version 2.10.5). 

Because of this, a little trickery was required to transfer my F3F setup from my TX16S to the GX12. After extracting the yaml file from the TX16S, I replaced the header and footer with corresponding sections of a setup already resident in the GX12. I also installed my crow aware trim script. It's all working fine. 

If you're an early adopter, I would advise flashing the latest version of EdgeTX.

Technical note: EdgeTX 2.11 promises some neat enhancements which will finally differentiate it from OpenTX. For example Diff, Weight and Offset can be number, or a GV, a channel or various other elements. 

Flight testing

Unfortunately LBT firmware is not yet available for the module (it's planned for ELRS 4) so flight tests will have to wait. When the time comes, I will use my Sting F3F slope racer equipped with Matek 24R P6V receiver (schhhh... it works on the bench!).  

Conclusion

Reviewing the GX12 has been a fascinating exercise - it's not often you get a set with so many interesting features.

Let's get one thing out of the way first: while the dual band capability is nice to have, it's not a 'must have' for line of sight pilots.

That said, there are some cool features for sailplane pilots such as the plug-in switches, configurable LED buttons and the folding sticks. And the gimbals, as one has come to expect from Radiomaster, are very good.

The GX12 isn't perfect though. A bit more height on the case would improve comfort for pilots who are used to the TX16S. And it's disappointing that the momentary buttons (the ones on the shoulders) cannot be swapped out for regular switches. I hope alternative switch panels are made available to deal with this.

So, will the GX12 displace my TX16S as my competition radio for F3F? No, because I prefer the ergonomics of the TX16S with AG01. And for DLG, I'll still be using the Zorro. And neither will the GX12 replace the Pocket for casual foamie use. In a sense, the GX12 is a jack of all trades but not quite excelling at any one thing.

Where I could see myself reaching for the GX12 is on trips abroad, when I need a radio which can do everything yet which takes up minimal space.

Finally, I should mention the GX12's price: just under £170 here in the UK, which is remarkably good considering its capabilities.

Once ETX 2.11 is stable and LBT firmware is available I plan to do some flight testing, and will update this review accordingly.

EU/UK users note: LBT firmware for the RF module is slated for ELRS V4, no release date available as yet.

Radiomaster GX12 specifications

  • Size: 183*148*78mm
  • Weight: 573g
  • Frequency: 2.400GHz and Sub-G 900MHz
  • Internal RF: ELRS 2.4GHz / Sub-G 900MHz
  • Supported Protocols: Express-LRS
  • Cooling Fan: Yes
  • Antenna: Dual folding 2.4GHz/ Sub-G 900MHz omni directional
  • RF: (Dual 1,000mW | Dual band XROSSBAND ELRS)
  • Voltage Range: 6.6 - 8.4V DC
  • Current: 390mA - 1000mA (Depending on Rf output)
  • Radio Firmware: EdgeTX (Transmitter) / ELRS (RF module)
  • Channels: Max 16 channels (Receiver dependent)
  • Battery: 7.4V 2-cell Lithium-Polymer / Two 3.7V 18650 Lithium-Ion cells (batteries not included)
  • Charging: 2s Smart Balance Charging
  • Connectivity: USB-C
  • Display: 128*64 Monochrome OLED display
  • Gimbal: GX01 1000Hz, 3D Digital CNC Hall Effect Gimbal with folding sticks
  • Gimbal Sticks: 3mm
  • External Module: Nano / Crossfire compatible
  • Upgrade Method: USB / EdgeTX Companion PC software
  • Memory: 512Mb Integrated Flash 

Package includes

  • 1 * GX12 Radio Controller
  • 1 * Signature Carry Case
  • 1 * 18650 Battery Tray
  • 2 * Replacement Switch Panels
  • 1 * Type-C Cable
  • 1 * Screen Protector
  • 1 * 1.5mm Hex Wrench
  • 4 * Low Tension Gimbals Springs
  • 1 * 2 Position Switch
  • 1 * Momentary Switch
  • 1 * RadioMaster Sticker Set
  • 1 * GX12 Manual

Links



4 comments:

Fotografi och ett rött hjärta said...

Hey Mike! Regarding the ETX Companion, the RM GX12 is included in the latest nightly companion 2.11.0, but I can't answer if everything works?

As far as EU/Lbt is concerned, it could possibly be the case that if you have 10mW of power, that will be the exception for Lbt? Something you might be able to investigate/apply..

https://github.com/EdgeTX/edgetx/actions/runs/12590467261

RC Soar said...

Thanks for the heads up re Companion. Not sure if the GX12 needs CE certification to fly legally in the UK - I suspect this is the case in which case it would not be legal with current firmware, regardless of power setting. (That said, it's already available for purchase in the UK.)

Anonymous said...

@RC Soar: the GX12 is indeed illegal to use within the eu, since it lacks CE. The importer into the eu, be it a consumer or business, has the full legal responsibility to provide a valid CE document and implicitly bears all legal risks when inporting the item in the eu.

If you are able to get it at an eu business, that business will bear all risk. If the end user makes an accident using that transmitter, the businessowner that inported the product must proof that the transmitter is legal to use within the eu. If they cant, they can have a big problem . They could even held liable for accidents that users of their illegally put to market transmitters did make.

Anonymous said...

No, since theres no ce the gx12 simply may not be used within the eu, even when output power is < 10mW